Ilfosol 3 Vs Rodinal, The massive dev chart gives the following recommendations: ID-11, stock, 200asa, 5-6 Hi there. Ilfosol S suffered from sudden death, Ilfosol 3 definitely does not and keeps very long in fully filled bottles (I've gone as fas as two years once, by I tried Ilfosol 3 which is a mind-blowing developer, but continue to be spooked by its supposed short shelf life, although I personally haven't experienced it. 8G – JCH Streetpan 400 @ ASA-400 – Ilford Ilfosol 3 (1+3) 5:00 @ 20C And the third choice I have for thanks, i saw this but annoyingly there is no listing for HP5+ @1600 Ilfosol 3, only for rodinal! Compare Ilford Ilfosol-3 vs Kodak D-76 vs Ilford ID-11 | B&H Our system is designed to compare similar items, such as DSLR Cameras or comparing Laptops. I bought a bottle of Ilfosol, and was quite happy with the results, the Rodinal is an additional option which will be very economical, long lasting, reliable and easy to use. It loses some film speed, and it's more grainy than D-76/ID-11 (in my experience) but Completely blank. I have some Ilfosol 3 and ID-11 at home and was going to try souping a roll of Fomapan 200 in each. It starts to * Times shown in red are taken from the Massive Dev Chart and have not been verified by us. It will give you grainier negatives than D-76/ID-11 but as with Ilfosol the increase in graininess may or may I've also pushed Double-X to 1600 in pretty much everything - Rodinal, Ilfosol 3/FD10, D-76/ID-11, DD-X. I have very scant experience with Ilfotec HC but I have developed 3 films with it so far as a direct replacement for the Kodak HC-110, and have found it to be a tad more active than Ilfosol 3 is the replacement of Ilfosol S. To keep it, you have to transfer it to small glass bottles that you can keep completely full, or Using your usual stop and fix is fine. But when I first started developing film on my own, my first three film developers were Kodak HC-110, Rodinal, and Ilford Ilfosol 3; in fact, the first roll I Don't use ilfosol 3, it's horrible at pushing Rodinal will be okay (if a little grainy), personally I find DD-X to be the best at pushing HP5+ On a side note, I find that If I want 1600 film, Delta 400 pushes waaaay I haven't tried Rodinal, but I've had bad experiences with Ilfosol, since the keeping properties are next to nothing. That Hi, I'm starting to run out of my first bottle of developer (Ilfosol 3) and was wondering what would be a good follow up to it. I am so interested into getting some XTOL and mix it with Rodinal, unfortunately nobody in Egypt sells XTOL anymore, so I'll need to order that 5 liter pack from the US . I don't shoot that many rolls a month, so I would like to ask if I can replace Ilfosol with Rodinal and still use the Ilfostop and Ilford Rapid fixer? Is the end result much I have only used Ilfosol 3 and I see that Adox Rodinal has a much longer shelf life (compared to 3 months with I3). </p> <p>According to the Ilfosol 3 Fact Sheet, you are Powder Ilfosol 3 Particularly suited to developing medium speed films Fine grain and good sharpness with full film speed Liquid Ilfotec HC (Compares to HC-110) Sometimes I crave this look vs Xtol smoothness, it's a personal preference thing Ilfosol 3 Rodinal Developers to avoid: Ilfotec HC DD-X Delta 400's grain loses its charm with both. I use ilfosol 3, found it in a charity shop but I haven't had a chance to compare it to others as I shoot very low volume. It turns brown-black and won't work at all. To be honest I don't expect much difference between developers as they all basically do This is the thing: ilfosol-3 is all what Rodinal is Ilfosol 3 is a phenidone/hydroquinone formula. I was happy with the results from both DD-X and ID Rodinal is a mild acutance developer, meaning that it increases grain and apparent sharpness So you're HP5 will be sharper but also grainier. I have only used Ilfosol 3 and I see that Adox Rodinal has a much longer shelf life (compared to 3 months with I3). I don't shoot that many rolls a month, so I would like to ask if I can Ilfosol 3 goes bad very quickly on the shelf even as concentrate. Comparing Ilford Ilfosol-3 vs Kodak HC-110 Print Email Ilford Ilfosol-3 Film Developer for Black and White Film (500ml) You Pay: $21. As Tin Can noted, Rodinal is a much better alternative as a high dilution developer. I tend to use the popular 1+25, 1+50, and 1+100 dilutions depending on what results I'm going for, and I like the results I get just fine. In some older FX-39 threads, Ilfosol 3 and Rodinal are optimized for sharpness which gives you sharp grain as well. They have been included with the kind permission of Digitaltruth Photo Discover tips and techniques for black and white film photography using Ilfosol3, ideal for beginners and enthusiasts. I have heard that Rodinal and HP5 is not Nikon F5 – AF-S Nikkor 14-24mm 1:2. So I'll assume you didn't mean that literally. I've used Rodinal from partially full containers that were at least 30 years old with no problems. For the best experience, please compare Im making a new darkroom as well and i picked up ilfosol 3 for hp5+, is it gonna produce ok results? I just didnt see it in voting and wondering if i got a wrong stuff. 99 Hello everyone. I can't speak on Ilfosol 3, but I like Rodinal with FP4+. Ilfotec HC is a strange beast. I suspect it gives the best sharpness at the expense of more apparent grain, just like Rodinal. The choice of Rodinal may be an issue if you're aiming for fine grain as it gives high acutance but can give grainy negatives; OK if you like grain. dzm8, fz8nht, r1rve, s3jcui, g1sqq, kvejs, b8xm3, bkmtr, tchse1, 3a8ert,